top of page
Search

Your Retention Problem May Be Who Stays

5 days ago
4 min read

When organizations talk about retention problems, they usually mean people are leaving. They worry about losing experience, the cost of replacing employees, and the time and money invested in someone who may take their skills somewhere else.


Those are legitimate concerns. I know how much work goes into hiring and developing an employee. But I have also seen situations where the bigger problem wasn’t who left. It was who stayed.


In last week’s article I talked about organizational pace cars. Some set a standard that helps everyone around them grow. Others establish a pace that teaches people to slow down, avoid responsibility, or stop looking for opportunities to contribute. When we talk about retention, we need to consider what we are keeping.


The Cost of the “Just Enough Guys”

Many organizations have what I call the “just enough guys.” They do just enough to get by and remain employed. Once they find a comfortable level of effort, they settle into it.


I am not talking about dependable employees who do their jobs well, work their scheduled hours, and go home. There is nothing wrong with that. I am talking about people who have learned how little they can contribute while continuing to benefit from the efforts of everyone around them.


I wrote a few months ago about the Bart Simpson cone of ignorance and how one low performer can create problems for an entire group. This is a deeper dive into that issue. Low performers and slow pace cars can hurt an organization more than we understand.


They don’t have to tell a new employee to lower their effort. Their example does the talking. A new employee hears what leadership says about ownership, teamwork, and accountability. Then they watch someone avoid responsibility, leave work for others, and remain comfortably in place. Which message are they supposed to believe?


The employee putting in more effort eventually has a reasonable question: Why am I working this hard when doing less seems to work just fine? Some people keep pushing despite what they see. Others adjust their effort to match the pace around them. And some look for another organization where their contribution might lead somewhere.


We readily calculate the cost of replacing someone. We should also ask what it is costing us to keep them. Nobody files a report for the frustration of picking up someone else’s work, the morale lost when effort goes unrewarded, or the energy spent having the same conversation again. Those costs compound quietly while the visible cost of turnover gets all the attention.


Good Pace Cars Prepare the People Behind Them

The pace car analogy works both ways. I have worked with great people who set a standard that made everyone around them better. They took ownership, cared about the work, and demonstrated what good performance looked like. The people behind them weren’t simply waiting for a position to open. They were watching, learning, and preparing.


We have lost some of those employees to opportunities at other organizations. Losing them wasn’t easy. They were good at their jobs, and they mattered to our organization.


But other organizations wanting our people can also be a byproduct of building a good organization. We help people develop skills, gain confidence, and become capable of greater responsibility. Sometimes an opportunity comes along that we cannot offer them at that moment. I don’t consider their development a mistake just because someone else eventually benefits from it.


In those situations, we have had the next person step up and take the work to another level. Other people shift into new responsibilities. Someone gets an opportunity they have been preparing for. The movement creates new life in the department.


That doesn’t mean the person who left wasn’t valuable. It means their value extended beyond the work they personally performed. They helped establish a pace that others were ready to carry forward.


A good pace car leaves people prepared to move. An underperforming pace car leaves people wondering whether they will ever get the chance.


A Healthy Organization Loses People

My friend once told me, “Train them so well that they can leave, treat them so well that they stay.” I like that idea, and it applies to a lot of people. But I also think you can do those things and good people will still leave because opportunity presents itself.


Think of a coaching tree in football. Coaches develop assistants who become capable of leading their own programs. When those assistants leave for head coaching jobs, it can be disappointing. It can also be evidence that the organization is developing people well.


A healthy organization does lose people. You develop talent, and you create opportunities for people to move forward. Sometimes that opportunity is within your organization. Sometimes it is somewhere else. Hiring and training new people can be difficult, but an evolving workplace ecosystem can be very healthy.


The goal isn’t to keep every seat occupied by the same person forever. It is to build an organization where people contribute, develop, and have opportunities to move forward.


What Are We Actually Retaining?

I want to keep good employees. I want people to build meaningful careers in our organization, and I want us to give them reasons to stay. But I don’t want us to confuse a lack of movement with a healthy organization.


Before we celebrate retention, we should ask what we are retaining. Are we preserving knowledge, ownership, and a standard that helps others grow? Or are we preserving habits and behaviors that discourage the people around us?


When someone leaves, we should ask more than how to prevent it from happening again. Did they leave because we failed to address a problem? Did they see no opportunity to advance? Or did they grow into an opportunity we can genuinely be proud of them for taking? Those are different situations, and they deserve different responses.


So before you ask how to keep more people, ask one other question: Who are you keeping, and what pace are they setting for everyone behind them? Look at the standard they model, the opportunities they create or block, and whether the people around them are becoming more capable.


Retention is only a success when what you keep helps the organization move forward.

 

 
 
 

Comments


bottom of page