top of page
Search

How to Be Direct Without Making People Feel Small

Oct 16
6 min read

When my son was about six years old, I told him we were going to have honest conversations about baseball. We were going to talk about his performance, the work he was putting in, and the things he needed to improve. I told him that if he wanted to get better, we needed to have a relationship where we could be honest with each other. Otherwise, it was not going to work. But I also told him that honesty needed to go both ways. If he thought I was pushing too hard, he needed to say something. I wanted him to know that his voice mattered just as much as mine.


He is ten now, and it has been interesting to watch that relationship develop. When he was younger, his feelings were hurt more easily. I might have been talking about a play or something he needed to work on, but it was still hard for him to hear. Now, he openly looks for my feedback. Most of the time, he volunteers his mistakes before I even have a chance to bring them up. He will tell me what he did wrong, and we can talk about what he might do differently next time. We are still figuring it out together, but those conversations look different than they did four years ago.


I do not want him to feel small when we talk about baseball. I do not want him to think that my opinion of him changes because he had a bad game or made a mistake. I want him to understand that we can look honestly at his performance without making it a judgment about who he is. I can love him, believe in him, and still tell him that there is something he needs to work on. Those things do not have to compete with each other.


A friend of mine who was a longtime baseball coach gave me a simple piece of advice. When a player makes a mistake, ask him, “What did you see?” I like that question because it does not start by telling the player everything he did wrong. It gives him a chance to explain what was happening from his perspective. Often, as he talks through the play, he identifies the mistake himself. Then we can coach the situation together instead of me jumping straight into a correction before I understand what he was thinking.


Maybe he threw to the wrong base because he misunderstood where the runner was going. Maybe he hesitated because he was unsure what we wanted him to do. I can see the result from where I am standing, but asking what he saw helps me understand how he got there. It also gives me a better place to start. Sometimes he needs help making a decision. Sometimes he needs something explained again. And sometimes his answer shows me that we have not taught him what he needed to know.


Recently, I talked with our baseball team about the difference between being nice and being kind. The way I explained it, being nice might mean saying nothing because we do not want someone to feel bad. Being kind means caring enough to have an honest conversation and helping them understand what to do next. I told them that if we want to get better, we have to be able to talk about what is happening on the field. That includes the things we are doing well, but it also includes the mistakes we are making.


Maybe someone threw to the wrong base. Maybe a player was not aggressive enough as a baserunner and missed an opportunity. Whatever happened, we try not to stop at telling them what they did wrong. We try to give them a path forward. We talk about what to look for, what decision to make, and what to do the next time they find themselves in that situation. I want them to leave the conversation with something they can use, not just the knowledge that their coach was unhappy with a play.


In those conversations, I also try to own our mistakes as coaches. Sometimes we need to say, “We should have taught you guys about that,” or, “We need to do a better job preparing you for that situation.” If we have not explained something or practiced it with them, we need to acknowledge our part. I want our players to know that they are not the only ones who have work to do. We need to get better as coaches too, and we are in this together.


We also remind them that baseball is a game of mistakes. They are going to make them, and I tell them that I made the same mistakes when I was their age. I threw to the wrong base. I hesitated when I should have been running. I had things I needed to learn too. I want them to know that I am not talking down to them from some place where I have always had everything figured out. I have been where they are. But I also know that the only way to work on a mistake is to be willing to address it.


When I think about my role as a leader, I see much of the same responsibility. The setting is different, but I am still working with people who need clear expectations, honest feedback, and an opportunity to improve. I do not want the people I lead to feel small any more than I want my son or our players to feel small. But I also do not want my concern about hurting their feelings to keep me from having a conversation they need and deserve.


One of the mistakes I see leaders make, and one I have to watch for in myself, is saying nothing. We see something that needs to be addressed, but we let it go. Maybe we are uncomfortable. Maybe we do not want to seem critical. Maybe we hope the person will recognize it and make the change on their own. Then it happens again, and we get a little more frustrated. Before long, we have built up a whole conversation in our heads that we have never actually had with the person.


That is where I have to stop and ask myself some questions. Have I made the expectation clear? Have I explained what I am seeing? Have I asked for their perspective? Have I helped them understand what to do differently, or have I just been upset that they are not doing it? It is not fair for me to withhold the coaching and then become frustrated that someone has not improved. My silence may help me avoid an uncomfortable moment, but it does not give them much to work with.

I can bring my friend’s question into those conversations too. “What did you see?” might become, “Walk me through what happened,” or, “What were you considering when you made that decision?” I want to understand before I assume. Their answer may reveal something they need to work on, but it may also reveal something I need to address. Maybe I was not clear. Maybe I assumed they knew something we had never discussed. Just like on the baseball field, I need to be willing to own my part.


That does not mean I need to point out every mistake or turn every conversation into a lesson. It means that when something matters enough to address, I want to address it clearly and thoughtfully. If a player throws to the wrong base, we can talk about that decision without labeling him a bad player. If someone at work misses an expectation, we can talk about what happened without turning it into a judgment about their character. I want to be specific about the problem and careful with the person.


I am still learning how to do this well. Being a dad, a coach, and a leader gives me plenty of opportunities to practice, and I do not always get the balance right. That is part of why I told my son he needed to be honest with me too. I need to know when my approach is getting in the way of what I am trying to help him learn. Being the person giving the feedback does not mean I have nothing to improve.


What I keep coming back to is what we want to happen after the conversation. On the field, I want a player to know what to do on the next play. At work, I want someone to understand the expectation and have a clearer idea of how to meet it. In both places, I want them to know that I still believe in them. The mistake is something we need to work on, not something that makes them less valuable to the team.


I do not want to choose between being honest and being kind. I want to get better at doing both. For me, that means saying what needs to be said, listening to what the other person has to say, and being willing to acknowledge where I need to improve too. Whether I am talking with my son after a baseball game or with an employee at work, I want the conversation to come from the same place: I care about you, I believe you can improve, and I am willing to work through this with you.


 
 
 

Comments


bottom of page